For this episode of Landowner Insider, I sat down with Marc Berger, CPA, founder of Crux Consulting, to talk about how owning a ranch affects your taxes and why the most important tax conversation happens before you buy. Marc is a longtime friend who helped Elizabeth and me early in our business, and he explains things in a way even I can follow. If your realtor isn’t having these conversations with you, you need a new realtor. This post is for education only and isn’t tax, legal, or financial advice, so talk with your own CPA and attorney before making decisions about your ranch.
Talk to Your CPA Before You Close
- Structure first: Marc says to get advisory help before you buy: how to hold the ranch, where the money should come from, whether to finance, and what your estate plan looks like if something happens the day after closing.
- The LLC problem: If you close personally with a loan, moving the ranch into an LLC later can mean refinancing, new closing costs, and possibly a higher rate.
- A real example: Marc described a doctor who was a week from closing with no LLC and no attorney. He had a new LLC and tax ID in place the day before closing, then set up a separate bank account and books.
Tax Preparer vs. Tax Advisor
- Different jobs: Marc described the typical CPA as someone who puts the right numbers in the right boxes. That’s compliance work, and it isn’t the same as advisory work.
- Capacity: Most CPAs are slammed and don’t have time to go deep, and many clients assume the CPA is also their CFO.
- My own story: Years ago, our return showed we were paying about 30 percent of gross revenue in income tax. A second opinion from Marc led to an amended return and tens of thousands of dollars in missed deductions.
- The standard I want: There can be a dozen ways to prepare a business return correctly. I want the one that pays the smallest percentage of tax that’s still defensible in an audit.
- Quarterly check-ins: Marc believes strategy should be revisited every quarter, not once a year.
The IRS Audit That Ended With the IRS Owing Us $62
- The scope: Before we hired Marc, the IRS did a baseline audit of every line item on three years of our returns. The auditor spent days in my office and hours in my PayPal account.
- The result: The IRS ended up owing us $62.
- Marc’s advice on audits: Don’t represent yourself, and have a professional handle the IRS. Marc says that auditors are early-career, overloaded, and trained to find unreported revenue, so a good representative sets the tone and documents a defensible position.
- Risk tolerance: Marc noted that most accountants are compliance-minded and risk-averse, while entrepreneurs live with thin margins and risk, and that mismatch is why advisors who can defend a position matter.
The Three Ways the IRS Sees a Ranch
- Recreational: A hobby ranch, where costs generally aren’t deductible.
- Passive investment: You hold it and capitalize your costs. Improvements like fences and water troughs build your basis but don’t offset income right away.
- Active business with material participation: This is the one that can let ranch losses offset other income, and it’s the hardest to prove.
Material Participation: Document Everything
- The tests: Marc described the 500-hour test, which works out to about 10 hours a week, and a 100-hour test that fails if someone else works more hours than you.
- The pitfall: Many owners believe they qualify but have no logs, no meeting notes, and no proof of the days they worked.
- What the IRS wants to see: A strategic plan that changes year to year, documented hours, regular meetings with the ranch manager, books and records, and receipts tied to a purpose.
- Ranch hands make it harder: If a manager runs the place day to day, it’s harder to show the owner is materially participating.
The Hobby Loss Rule
- The trigger: Marc said the common test is a profit in three of the last five years.
- A win in an audit: He described a client with ten years of Schedule F losses who won a no-change audit. Their plan showed the cattle herd growing from about 100 cows to more than 400, so the balance sheet was growing even while the P&L showed losses.
- The lesson: A business plan, books, and an asset-building strategy can show you’re operating a business, not a hobby.
The Legacy Nutrient Deduction (Section 180)
- How it works: A third-party study estimates the nutrients in the ground. Marc compared it to a cost segregation study on a building. In his example, a $1 million ranch might carry $300,000 of legacy nutrients, which can be depreciated.
- The math he used: At a 30 percent tax bracket, a $300,000 deduction would be roughly $100,000 in tax savings.
- Requirements: It generally requires a real agricultural operation with material participation, not a hobby ranch.
- Existing ranch: If you bought years ago, Marc said you may be able to claim it through a Form 3115 change in accounting method, but it’s complicated and not every CPA does them often.
- Who benefits: Mostly owners with income elsewhere to offset. Marc said it isn’t applicable to many traditional producers without that income.
- Spend the money to do it right: It costs several thousand dollars and up, and Marc advises using a reputable study firm such as Bird Dog instead of the cheapest option. Once the deduction is on your return, you still have to document your participation in later years.
- Not for flippers: Marc suggests holding three to five years, because selling sooner recaptures the accelerated depreciation.
- Partnerships work too: If an LLC or partnership owns the ranch, the deduction flows through to the owners on their K-1s.
- Inheritance: Marc said that, under current law, inherited ranches can get a step-up in basis and possibly a fresh deduction, but he warned that rules may change.
Exotic Breeding Operations
- Not the same as a hunting ranch: Marc noted that hunting doesn’t qualify as an agricultural function in the way breeding does.
- How the structure works: Operations like those promoted by Wildlife Partners are built around a true breeding program, where you build inventory, sell offspring, and grow the herd, treated like a cattle breeding operation.
- The catch: The strategy still has to “walk and talk and quack like a duck.” That means real accounting, records, and a profitability plan, and many CPAs are uncomfortable signing returns for strategies they consider fringy.
Common Mistakes Ranch Owners Make
- Commingling: If your construction company’s crew and equipment work on your ranch, Marc says to paper it: have the company invoice the ranch, even at a discounted rate, and have the ranch pay the bill.
- No separate entity or books: Your ranch needs its own LLC, books, and bank account.
- 1099s: The IRS looks for reasonableness. Issue as many 1099s as you can, but don’t stress over a $125-a-week mower.
- No liability waivers: Marc described a ranch day with 20 people shooting skeet and riding ATVs and no signed release. He recommends durable, digital waivers that also address who can post photos of the property.
- Cash to college kids: If a part-time hand gets bucked off, the ranch needs an agreement in place before the day starts.
- Outdated estate plans: Wills that are 20 years old, no trust, and no family meetings leave ranch families stuck. Marc’s rule: fair isn’t always equal, and the biggest cause of family division is not planning.
Marc’s Takeaway and RIM
- RIM (Ranching Integrated Management): Crux’s new ranch service, built from client questions, brings together accounting, bookkeeping, and tax strategy, with partners for ag worker visas and pasture rain insurance.
- Measure it to manage it: Marc’s advice to ranchers is to know your monthly costs and profit, because without good accounting you can’t make good decisions.
- Marc’s closing line: Dot your I’s and cross your T’s.
Watch the Full Episode
This article is based on my conversation with Marc Berger of Crux Consulting on Landowner Insider.
Work With Mock Ranches
Understanding the tax and structure side of a ranch before you buy puts you in a stronger position. Explore Texas ranches for sale or all Texas land for sale at mockranches.com, and see our conversation with banker Brock Demere on whether you’re financially ready to buy Texas land.
About Marc Berger and Crux Consulting
Thanks to Marc Berger, CPA, founder of Crux Consulting, which provides accounting, tax strategy, and advisory services for business owners and landowners. Marc previously co-founded McGinnis & Berger, a firm acquired by LegalZoom. Learn more at thecruxtx.com.